Elton John Reveals He Scraps Songs If a Melody Doesn’t Work in an Hour
Updated Dec 16
Legendary musician Elton John shares his approach to songwriting, revealing the importance of intuition and spontaneity in creating timeless music.
Elton John, one of the greatest songwriters and performers in music history, has revealed an intriguing detail about his creative process. The iconic artist shared that he will scrap a song if he cannot develop a compelling melody within an hour. This candid insight sheds light on John’s uncompromising approach to his craft and his dedication to maintaining a high standard in his work.
The Secret to a Legendary Career
Elton John’s career spans over five decades, during which he has delivered countless hits, from Rocket Man to Your Song and Tiny Dancer. His ability to create enduring melodies has earned him a place among the all-time greats, with over 300 million records sold worldwide.
In a recent interview, John explained his philosophy on songwriting: “If I can’t nail the melody in an hour, I just move on. It has to come naturally. If it feels forced, it’s not going to work.” For John, inspiration must flow effortlessly, and this instinct-driven process has been key to his success.
Trusting the Creative Process
John’s revelation highlights the importance of intuition in songwriting. Unlike some artists who labor over compositions for days or weeks, John relies on his instincts to guide the process. His partnership with lyricist Bernie Taupin, one of the most celebrated collaborations in music history, is a testament to this method.
Taupin typically provides the lyrics, and John crafts melodies around them. This dynamic approach has yielded some of the most memorable songs in history. “When I see Bernie’s words, the melody either comes instantly, or it doesn’t come at all,” John said. “It’s always been like that.”
This method of trusting his gut has allowed John to maintain a prolific output without compromising on quality. It also speaks to his self-awareness as an artist, recognising when to let go of ideas that aren’t working and focus on those that do.
Lessons for Aspiring Musicians
Elton John’s process offers valuable lessons for aspiring songwriters and musicians. His willingness to abandon a song that doesn’t come together quickly may seem counterintuitive, but it underscores the importance of authenticity in creative work. By focusing on what feels natural and inspired, rather than forcing ideas, John ensures that his music connects with listeners on a deeper level.
This approach also highlights the significance of collaboration in the creative process. John credits much of his success to his partnership with Bernie Taupin, emphasising the value of finding collaborators who complement and enhance your work.
Fans React to Elton’s Insight
Fans have responded enthusiastically to John’s comments, praising his honesty and insight into the creative process. Social media buzzed with admiration for the legendary artist, with many fans reflecting on how his timeless melodies have impacted their lives.
One fan wrote, “Elton John trusting his instincts is why his music feels so real. It’s incredible to get a glimpse into his process.” Another added, “This explains why his songs are so iconic—they’re born out of pure inspiration.”
A Legacy of Unmatched Creativity
Elton John’s ability to consistently create memorable music is a testament to his talent, discipline, and authenticity. By setting high standards for himself and knowing when to walk away from an idea, he has built a catalogue of songs that resonate with audiences across generations.
As he continues to perform and record music, John remains a beacon of inspiration for artists everywhere. His approach serves as a reminder that great art often comes from trusting your instincts and being willing to let go of what doesn’t work.
Looking Ahead
As Elton John wraps up his Farewell Yellow Brick Road tour, which marks the end of his touring career, his influence on the music world remains as strong as ever. Fans can look forward to more music from the legendary artist, as he has hinted at ongoing studio projects.
John’s candid insights into his creative process are a gift to the music community, offering a rare glimpse into the mind of a true genius. Whether he’s crafting new melodies or performing his timeless classics, Elton John continues to set the standard for excellence in music.