The release of the 2024 Ultimate Mix of Do They Know It’s Christmas? has ignited heated debates, particularly over the decision by Bob Geldof to exclude the Band Aid II version from the new compilation. This omission erases the contributions of key artists from the 1989 rendition, including Bananarama (Sara Dallin and Keren Woodward), Kylie Minogue, Jason Donovan, Lisa Stansfield, Wet Wet Wet, Bros, Sonia, and Big Fun. These performers, who were pivotal to the late 1980s music scene, now find their efforts omitted from the song's official legacy.

The controversy doesn’t stop there. The new release, featuring stars like Ed Sheeran, Harry Styles, Bono, Chris Martin, Sting, and Paul McCartney, has drawn criticism beyond its lineup. Ed Sheeran has publicly condemned the use of his vocals without proper consent, while Fuse ODG has reiterated his long-standing critique of the song’s messaging, arguing that it perpetuates outdated and harmful stereotypes about Africa. Fuse ODG has called for a shift in how Africa is represented in global media, emphasizing the importance of the continent telling its own stories and solving its challenges without reliance on Western narratives.

Bob Geldof has defended the song and its legacy, highlighting its altruistic goals. “This little pop song has saved millions of lives,” Geldof stated, underlining the billions raised for humanitarian efforts since its original release in 1984. However, critics argue that while the intentions were noble, the execution reinforces condescending and paternalistic views of Africa that have no place in modern charity campaigns.

The controversy has reignited broader discussions about the framing of charitable efforts and the need for such projects to evolve. As global audiences demand narratives that reflect dignity, respect, and agency, the debate surrounding Do They Know It’s Christmas? becomes a stark reminder of the complexities in balancing charity with cultural sensitivity.

Meanwhile, fans can hear every version of the iconic song, including Band Aid and Band Aid II’s renditions, on The Best of Christmas Pop on YouRadio.